
Woodstock-based indie-garage-rock band Your Favorite Person have just released their sophomore album Mutate or Die on October 10th. Following their debut 2024 record In a World That’s Always Ending, the band is really exploring and establishing their unique sound and voice with this new album. What strikes me most is their refreshingly unusual songwriting choices that feel very fluent and stream of conscious rather than bound to traditional compositional conventions–they’re erratic and unpredictable, keeping listeners curious and on their toes. Fans of Pavement and Modest Mouse will feel right at home among YFP’s jangly riffs and raw vocals–the strained yelling and occasional voice breaks clearly convey certain emotions more viscerally than words alone ever could. It’s inspiring to see how these guys came together with such natural chemistry to create a sound all their own in a matter of only a few years. I have a special affinity for this band as I, too, am a sucker for gritty garage rock, and I’m psyched to be sharing the stage with them once again–definitely make a point to catch them live at DIY Kingston Fest Saturday 11/21–they’ll be playing at Keegan Ales at 7:00 PM (tickets).

Your Favorite Person is made up of Matthew Brady (vocals/guitar), Nighttrain Schickele (vocals/guitar), Luke Fisher (bass/backup vocals), and Ben Hansen (drums/backup vocals). While Brady is the head songwriter of the group, all members pitch in to the songwriting process. The band had this to say about the new album: “Recorded in our garage between October 4th and October 20th, 2025. We’ve been playing many of these songs for over 2 years and have had the pleasure to really live with them and let them change and evolve over time. We wanted to make something powerful and succinct, and push out from the edges of what we did on the first album. This record is full of love and we hope it provides a pleasant escape, or a spark of inspiration, or some fun.” I think “pleasant escape” is a great way to describe this release, as many of the songs are pretty lengthy and take you on a journey, allowing you to zone out and Zen out a bit as you get lost and enmeshed in the songs, guided by their sporadic winds and bends. It’s mesmerizing listening to how the band seems to create their own language among each other through their irregular song structures and cryptic lyrics–it’s as if they’re inviting you in to experience their perspective and have a conversation.

The album opens with “A Normal Life,” a melancholic rocker that seems to be saying, “I know I’m a weirdo, and while I love you unconditionally, I ultimately just want you to have a great, normal life, even if that means taking me out of the equation.” In rapid syllabic fashion, Brady sings, “Lost and found and tossed around again / I was caught and bound and hounded down ravines / I know nothing about your dreams / I just wanna know what you got up your sleeves / Till I decide I’m not here again, say it again / You deserve somebody normal / …You deserve a life that’s normal / But I can’t help you out right now.” The falsetto backup vocals add a strangely distinctive texture to the mix, an element that recurs throughout the album. The first half of the song consists of a series of starts and stops, building up and breaking down between the verses and choruses, and then the latter half picks up, unleashing some ripping riffs, before returning to standard time and repeating the chorus for the outro.

The songs’ durations vary drastically, with the shortest song being 0:59 and the longest clocking in at 8:53. Funnily enough, these two songs are a couple of my favorite on the album for different reasons. Track two, “There is a Heaviness to All Things Here,” while it’s only a minute long, it serves as a sort of microcosm of YFP’s music in general and piques your interest to come on in and take a look around. In contrast to the rest of the songs, this one is more stripped bare. A simple, pensive guitar progression plays, a harmonica drones, and Brady sings, “The noise in the checkered blue theater…” while the backup singers chime in and hang on the last note–“…blew Andy right out the womb / The toys are electing a new leader when Andy’s not in his room.” We love a Toy Story reference, especially when it seems to be referring to the puppeteers of society pulling the strings behind the scenes unbeknownst to us–classic. The band sings in unison, “There is a heaviness to all things here / There is a heaviness to all things here,” and then Brady sings alone, “It’s so hard to seize the day / It’s so hard to be okay,” concluding the short-but-sweet song. The longest track, “Fuck You Money,” is probably my number one on the album. It’s groovy, catchy, and keeps you engaged throughout all its many parts over the near 9-minute duration. In a melody that will get stuck in your head, Brady repeats this line: “I don’t want to live upside down / Oh, I’m gonna spin around.” The vibe of the song is evocative of Collective Soul’s “Shine” in that it’s midtempo and chill during the verses, and the choruses get louder and larger, before chilling back out. Later on the song gets chaotic and cathartic–the sonic equivalent of a rage room–building and building and then ending abruptly Beatles’ style.

Your Favorite Person has become one of my favorite Hudson Valley bands in recent years. I always have them top of mind whenever I’m booking local shows (and so should you). This new album is full of really interesting, wonderfully weird, and captivating songs with contagious hooks and hypnotic tangents. Some of my other faves are “The Strongest Person in the World,” “IDK” (check out the music video below!), and the last track on the album, “Mind Like a Pencil,” an unhinged singalong to end the record off on a wacky, happy-go-lucky note. I encourage you to follow the band and listen to Mutate or Die from start to finish. These guys are on a roll with their first two albums, and I’m psyched to see what they cook up next.
(P.S. – New Hampshire should consider updating their motto.)
Your Favorite Person’s social and streaming links:
Watch their music video for “IDK”:
Buy the album on Bandcamp
-Review written by James Kwapisz

Leave a Reply